
We've gotta say we were a bit surprised when a tiny comment we made about Dream Theater last week was perceived as an act of character assassination and prompted a slew of nasty comments from irate fans. One thing's for sure, those Dream Theater followers sure take their role as defenders of the Dream seriously.
But actually, their sabres were drawn pretty abruptly. We didn't really insult Dream Theater. All we said was that we were surprised Headbangers Ball viewers voted the band's video for "Constant Motion" the second best metal video of the year. We were even more shocked that the number one pick was Mushroomhead's "12 Hundred," but that's another argument entirely.
In our post, we pointed out that we "begged to differ" with the viewer's decision, then we premiered Dream Theater's new video for "Forsaken" on the blog because we believed strongly that the band's sizable fanbase wanted to see the clip. Two days later, we debuted the video on Heabangers Ball on MTV2. Pardon our hubris, but we don't see Fuse, VH1 or BET giving such love to Dream Theater.
Of course, there are two sides to every coin. Dream Theater are obviously ambitious, musically gifted and versed in a variety of styles. They're tighter than Barbie's ass and adventurous enough to improvise instead of always following their songs note for note. But that doesn't mean the "Constant Motion" video was more visually breathtaking than offerings by Mastodon, Machine Head or Down. There's a clear difference between sight and sound and sometimes the best songs are accompanied by some pretty crappy videos.
Now on to more inflammatory matters. While Dream Theater's legions obviously covet their favorite band above their own families, there are others who feel the group's endless soloing is self-indulgent, and that its complex arrangements don't hold together as well as simple, well-crafted songs. Also, while Dream Theater's songs obviously contain melodies, some argue that the emphasis on musicianship detracts from the tunefulness of the material. Even some fans of progressive metal groups such as Opeth, Mars Volta, Protest the Hero and System of a Down will argue that there's a big difference between experimentation and narcissistic showmanship, and that true musical revelation comes from an emphasis on art, not virtuosity.
That said, we'll continue to support Dream Theater as a valid force in hard rock/metal, however there are certainly plenty of other artists that are just as viable and to disregard bands such as Slayer, Killswitch Engage or Behemoth simply because they may lack Dream Theater's chops is as narrowminded as writing off Dream Theater as smarty-pants show-offs.
We await your invective.